The official definition of interoperability, as put forth by the ONC (Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology), is “the ability of two or more systems to exchange health information and use the information once it is received.” However, if you google the term you’ll find dozens of different definitions, each with a slightly different slant. At the core of all these definitions, however, is the sharing and accessing of data.
According to HIMSS (Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society), there are four levels of interoperability.
- Foundational (Level 1): Establishes the inter-connectivity requirements needed for one system or application to securely communicate data to and receive data from another
- Structural (Level 2): Defines the format, syntax and organization of data exchange including at the data field level for interpretation
- Semantic (Level 3): Provides for common underlying models and codification of the data including the use of data elements with standardized definitions from publicly available value sets and coding vocabularies, providing shared understanding and meaning to the user
- Organizational (Level 4): Includes governance, policy, social, legal and organizational considerations to facilitate the secure, seamless and timely communication and use of data both within and between organizations, entities and individuals. These components enable shared consent, trust and integrated end-user processes and workflows
Why do we need interoperability in healthcare?
In addition to the numerous clinical reasons to achieve interoperability, there is opportunity for the back-office administration of healthcare—which includes processes such as eligibility verification, prior authorization, claims submission, and charge capture. These processes are often fragmented, full of manual and error-prone workflows, and so inefficient that they cost the U.S. nearly half a trillion dollars each year, with billing, coding, physician administrative duties, and insurance administration being the primary drivers.
The current ways to connect for administrative transactions rely on a web of single-use, point-to-point connections and batch or call and response processes that lack data control and traceability. Payers and providers have invested millions in multiple platforms to modernize, but still lack full integration and interoperable functionality.
How does the lack of interoperability affect payers and providers?
One of the most significant issues caused by a lack of interoperability is friction between payers and providers. It’s understandable why a lack of transparency has created such high levels of distrust. Fraud, waste, and abuse cost payers billions each year, which is why they now use more sophisticated technology to identify potential claim issues. While this may help reduce fraud and overpayments, it has also caused more work for providers via increasingly complex payer requirements that are hard to keep up with.
The bottom line is that payers want to reduce their financial risk by ensuring that members receive the most cost-effective, appropriate level of care. At the same time, providers want autonomy around the decisions they make when caring for their patients, and they expect fair, timely compensation for that care. Both want to simplify the extreme administrative complexities caused by a lack of interoperability and data fluidity.
How does the lack of interoperability affect patients?
Administrative inefficiencies caused by a lack of interoperability can impact both a patient’s health and wallet. Prior authorization is a great example. In a 2022 survey by the American Medical Association, 94% of providers said the prior authorization process had caused delays in patient care, and 33% said those delays in care have caused a serious adverse event for patients.
The lack of financial transparency is another issue that impacts patients. When providers can’t tell patients with certainty what they will owe, it limits those patients’ ability to make informed decisions about when and where to get care and how to pay for it. This lack of transparency can negatively impact the entire patient experience, even offsetting a positive clinical experience. While the No Surprises Act has pushed the industry forward, there is much room for improvement.
Why is interoperability in healthcare so difficult to achieve?
The banking industry seems to have interoperability figured out. Consumers can easily send money to other people with no more than an email address or phone number, even outside their own banking system. And they can go to virtually any ATM anywhere in the world, see their account balance, and withdraw funds.
The primary reason interoperability in healthcare is so challenging is that payers and providers use multiple methods to exchange information, including:
- Exclusive networks built by EHRs
- Clearinghouse networks and solutions
- Clinical networks
- Data and solution platforms
- API-centric companies
- Health data exchanges and health information exchanges (HIEs)
- Standards and frameworks like FHIR(R), EDI, EHNAC, CAQH, NCQA, WEDI
All these methods deliver some level of interoperability but require the implementation and maintenance of point-to-point connections with each trading partner. And most of these connections use request-response workflows that delay data and require the aggregation and storage of data by third parties.
Another challenge is a lack of standardization. While Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resource (FHIR) has given us a common set of protocols and standards for a payload of transactions on a network, FHIR alone does not translate into interoperability and data fluidity. It is still a highly complex system of multiple data gateways.
Are there any solutions that help solve interoperability challenges in healthcare?
The answer is “Yes!” In a truly interoperable healthcare ecosystem, data would not need to be requested, aggregated, and validated each time it is needed. Instead, it would be continuously refreshed, always current, and accessible in real time via a single network to those who are permissioned to access it. It’s a new way of conducting the business of healthcare and it’s here today via the Avaneer Health Network™.
The Avaneer Health Network™ is a secure, permissioned, decentralized network and platform built on a data fabric infrastructure. Once a participant—payer, provider, or innovator—connects to the network, there is not a need to build a direct connection to any other participant. Data remains decentralized, and participants can control how and with whom they collaborate. Through a permissioned process, their data can be shared with anyone on the network whom they have approved to receive it. Once the connection is established, data can flow freely in real time, eliminating interoperability barriers and allowing genuine data fluidity.
How the Avaneer Health Network™ connects healthcare
Each participant receives an Avaneer SparkZone™, a dedicated, private, secure, cloud-hosted environment. The SparkZone is the connection between the participant’s internal system and the network, facilitating direct peer-to-peer data access with a suite of utilities and services for FHIR transformation. In addition, subscribed solution apps are loaded into the SparkZone.
Another important component of the Avaneer Network is Avaneer Collaboration Services™, which includes multiple tools and resources to facilitate interconnectivity. These services include a person-centric identity service that links person identities across network participants so that there is a shared context. Then, the Collaboration Service enable fluid and direct data exchange across the Avaneer Network. Governance of more than 20 autonomously administered security controls enforces authentication, authorization, access controls and audit controls to ensure data access is fully permissioned, auditable, and decentralized.
The Avaneer Network also provides a digital marketplace, the Avaneer Solution Exchange™, where participants can discover, offer, and source other solutions on the Avaneer Network. It’s a shared resource for the entire community of participants.
What’s next for interoperability in healthcare?
With each new technology that launches, the potential for innovation in healthcare increases exponentially. To successfully leverage and deploy innovative solutions requires a level of interoperability that supports collaboration and connectivity in a new way. With Avaneer Health, many of healthcare’s biggest challenges, both administrative and clinical, are resolved.
We invite you to join Avaneer Health on our journey to reinvent the business of healthcare.